A sourced buyer’s guide

Broken-link monitoring, side by side.

A five-tool comparison for shop owners weighing broken-link detection, repair claims, reporting and price. The findings below preserve the completed alternatives report; vendor repair statements are not independent test results.

Reviewed 17 November 2026

Detailed comparison

Compare the evidence by topic

“Not established” means the supplied report did not establish the point; it is not a claim that a feature is absent.

StoreFix

Shopify product SEO and broken-link remediation.

Coverage and detection

Internal broken-link detection
Vendor claim: detects broken links [1].
Broken bookmarks or jump links

A broken fragment points to a page, but not to the intended section.

Not established.
Incoming external-request tracking
Not established.
External backlink changes
No; the report says it does not change external backlinks [10].
Product-level issues and scan scope
Vendor claim: Shopify Admin API work on meta titles, meta descriptions and alt text [1].
Store scan cadence
Not established.

Repair and workflow

Redirect creation and destination matching

Repair statements are vendor assertions unless explicitly described as official tool documentation.

Vendor claim: detects 404s and creates redirects through Shopify Admin API, including bulk remediation [10].
Suggestions and product-data assistance
Vendor claim: AI text is grounded in existing product data; generated alt text uses product titles [1].
Saved values and undo
Vendor claim: saves previous values for one-click undo [1].
Repair verification

No independent repair-outcome testing or audit was found in the report.

Claims to rerun its audit immediately after fixes [10].

Fit and oversight

Small-store fit
Not established.
Mid-to-large-store fit
Scalability benchmarks are not established.
DIY or manual-control fit
The report describes it as automation-led and not suited to a manual preference [1].
Analytics or reporting
Not established.
Bulk export
Not established.

Pricing in the completed report

Free or freemium option
No free tier; the report lists Pro and Plus plans [1].
Lowest paid tier
Pro: £29/month with a 7-day free trial [1].
Second or Plus tier
Plus: £79/month with a 7-day free trial [1].

LinkHealer

Product-catalogue matching and 404 redirect claims.

Coverage and detection

Internal broken-link detection
Vendor claim: checks store product URLs and product information [2].
Broken bookmarks or jump links

A broken fragment points to a page, but not to the intended section.

Not established.
Incoming external-request tracking
Not established.
External backlink changes
Not established.
Product-level issues and scan scope
Vendor claim: uses store product URLs and product information [2].
Store scan cadence
Not established.

Repair and workflow

Redirect creation and destination matching

Repair statements are vendor assertions unless explicitly described as official tool documentation.

Vendor claim: creates permanent 301 redirects to relevant products [3].
Suggestions and product-data assistance
Vendor claim: smart repair suggestions use product information [2].
Saved values and undo
Not established.
Repair verification

No independent repair-outcome testing or audit was found in the report.

Not established.

Fit and oversight

Small-store fit
Not established.
Mid-to-large-store fit
Not established.
DIY or manual-control fit
Not established.
Analytics or reporting
Vendor claim: tracks fixed or redirected links; broader analytics are not established [2].
Bulk export
Not established.

Pricing in the completed report

Free or freemium option
Yes in the report matrix; free-tier terms are not established. Narrative lists £4.99/month [3].
Lowest paid tier
£4.99/month is the price stated in the report narrative [3].
Second or Plus tier
Not established.

404 Link Monitor

Daily store scans and incoming 404 tracking claims.

Coverage and detection

Internal broken-link detection
Yes; vendor claim [4].
Broken bookmarks or jump links

A broken fragment points to a page, but not to the intended section.

Not established.
Incoming external-request tracking
Tracks incoming external requests; vendor claim [4].
External backlink changes
Not established.
Product-level issues and scan scope
Vendor claim: includes alt-text and meta-tag tools [5].
Store scan cadence
Vendor claim: scans the store daily [4].

Repair and workflow

Redirect creation and destination matching

Repair statements are vendor assertions unless explicitly described as official tool documentation.

Vendor claim: redirects broken links to existing pages automatically [4].
Suggestions and product-data assistance
Vendor claim: automated fixing suggestions [5].
Saved values and undo
Not established.
Repair verification

No independent repair-outcome testing or audit was found in the report.

Not established.

Fit and oversight

Small-store fit
Not established.
Mid-to-large-store fit
Not established.
DIY or manual-control fit
Not established.
Analytics or reporting
Vendor claim: simple link analytics and per-link details [5].
Bulk export
Not established.

Pricing in the completed report

Free or freemium option
Free plan exists [5].
Lowest paid tier
Not established; a free plan is reported [5].
Second or Plus tier
Not established.

404Shield

Store scans, live 404 monitoring and suggested redirects.

Coverage and detection

Internal broken-link detection
Vendor claim: scans store content for 404s [6].
Broken bookmarks or jump links

A broken fragment points to a page, but not to the intended section.

Not established.
Incoming external-request tracking
Vendor claim: tracks live 404 requests from visitors [6].
External backlink changes
Not established.
Product-level issues and scan scope
Vendor claim: scans products, collections, pages and blogs [6].
Store scan cadence
Not established.

Repair and workflow

Redirect creation and destination matching

Repair statements are vendor assertions unless explicitly described as official tool documentation.

Vendor claim: individual and bulk redirects, with AI destination suggestions [6][7].
Suggestions and product-data assistance
Vendor claim: AI suggests relevant redirect destinations [6].
Saved values and undo
Not established.
Repair verification

No independent repair-outcome testing or audit was found in the report.

Not established.

Fit and oversight

Small-store fit
Single merchant report: “We run a small business, so we didn't have a huge number of broken links to deal with, but 404Shield made it really easy to find and fix the ones we did have” [6].
Mid-to-large-store fit
Scalability is not established.
DIY or manual-control fit
Manual-control fit is not established.
Analytics or reporting
Vendor claim: analytics, alerts and 404 history [6][7].
Bulk export
Vendor listing reports bulk redirect export [7].

Pricing in the completed report

Free or freemium option
Free tier exists [6].
Lowest paid tier
£19.99/month [6].
Second or Plus tier
Not established.

Screaming Frog SEO Spider

A crawler for SEO auditing and broken-link detection.

Coverage and detection

Internal broken-link detection
Yes; official Response Codes tab and Client Error (4XX) filter [8].
Broken bookmarks or jump links

A broken fragment points to a page, but not to the intended section.

Yes; checks fragment IDs against page HTML and lists them in the URL tab’s Broken Bookmark filter [9].
Incoming external-request tracking
Not established.
External backlink changes
Not established.
Product-level issues and scan scope
Product-level issue coverage not established.
Store scan cadence
Manual crawler; recurring scan cadence not established [8].

Repair and workflow

Redirect creation and destination matching

Repair statements are vendor assertions unless explicitly described as official tool documentation.

Detection and auditing only; no built-in repair [8][9].
Suggestions and product-data assistance
Not applicable; the report describes detection and auditing only [8][9].
Saved values and undo
Not applicable; no built-in repair [8][9].
Repair verification

No independent repair-outcome testing or audit was found in the report.

Not applicable; no repair capability is attributed to it [8][9].

Fit and oversight

Small-store fit
The report describes the free crawl limit of 500 URLs as suitable for smaller sites [8].
Mid-to-large-store fit
Paid version crawls more than 500 URLs; broader fit benchmarks are not established [8].
DIY or manual-control fit
Suitable for DIY auditing; the report describes it as a manual audit tool [8][9].
Analytics or reporting
Filterable crawl results and exported inlinks [9].
Bulk export
Exports broken bookmarks and inlinks in bulk [9].

Pricing in the completed report

Free or freemium option
Free crawl up to 500 URLs [8].
Lowest paid tier
Not established.
Second or Plus tier
Not established; paid version is required above 500 URLs [8].

Tatterkite

Tatterkite’s repair boundary

Tatterkite shop monitoring is in development and is not live. A future automatic link correction would be limited to a correction judged safe and would require writable access from the shop platform. Without that permission, or when a correction cannot be judged safe, the issue would be flagged for owner review. A repair not made will not be described as complete.

Evidence and limits

Evidence reminder: competitor features, prices and repair statements from vendor listings are claims, not independent validation. Repair and destination-matching statements for StoreFix, LinkHealer, 404 Link Monitor and 404Shield remain unverified. The report found no independent audit of repair outcomes, no quantified success or error rates, and no independent validation of destination accuracy or link-equity preservation. Screaming Frog claims here are from its official documentation and describe detection/auditing, not repair. Prices reproduce the report snapshot in GBP; verify current terms with each vendor before buying.

The supplied report snapshot includes references [1]–[10] but not its source ledger. The links below are publicly accessible pages recovered for the corresponding claim topics; their exact one-to-one match with the omitted original references cannot be confirmed. Report findings and GBP values are preserved as supplied.

Reading the matrix

Vendor feature, pricing and repair statements are labelled as claims. “Not established” means the report did not establish the point; missing evidence is not treated as a negative capability finding.

Claim references

Source pages

Select a citation number in the table to jump here.

  1. [1] vendor listing · Shopify App Store

    StoreFix — Shopify App Store listing

    Open source page
  2. [2] vendor listing · Shopify App Store

    LinkHealer — Shopify App Store listing

    Open source page
  3. [3] third-party listing · PickYourApp

    LinkHealer — product and pricing listing

    Open source page
  4. [4] vendor listing · Shopify App Store

    404 Link Monitor — Shopify App Store listing

    Open source page
  5. [5] third-party listing · PickYourApp

    404 Link Monitor — product listing

    Open source page
  6. [6] vendor listing · Shopify App Store

    404Shield — Shopify App Store listing

    Open source page
  7. [7] third-party listing · PickYourApp

    404Shield — product and pricing listing

    Open source page
  8. [8] official documentation · Screaming Frog

    How to find broken links using SEO Spider

    Open source page
  9. [9] official documentation · Screaming Frog

    How to find broken bookmarks and jump links

    Open source page
  10. [10] vendor listing · StoreFix

    StoreFix — pricing and feature page

    Open source page

Talk through your shop’s link issues

Contact Tatterkite with questions about shop monitoring and the access needed to apply a safe link correction.

Contact Tatterkite